Both promise home-cooked meals under $6 per serving. But Dinnerly and EveryPlate take different approaches to keeping costs low. We break down every difference — price, portions, variety, and long-term value.
Every major factor, side by side.
| Category | Dinnerly | EveryPlate |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price/serving | $4.99 Cheaper | $4.99–$7.49 |
| Shipping | $9.99/week | $9.99/week |
| Weekly recipes | 15–20 options | 25+ options More variety |
| Dietary filters | Limited (basic) | Better (family, veggie, quick meals) |
| Portion size | Adequate, some find small | Generous Better portions |
| Recipe complexity | Simple (3–6 ingredients) | Simple to moderate |
| Cook time | 20–35 min | 25–40 min |
| App quality | Good | Good (HelloFresh parent) |
| Pause/skip | Easy | Easy |
| Add-ons (proteins, extras) | Limited | Limited |
| First-order discount | ~60% off first box | ~50% off first box |
| Parent company | Marley Spoon Group | HelloFresh Group |
| Best for | Absolute budget seekers | Value-seeking families Editor's Pick |
Dinnerly starts at $4.99/serving for a 4-person, 5-recipe plan. EveryPlate matches at the low end but can climb to $7.49/serving on smaller plans. Both tack on a $9.99 flat shipping fee, which matters less the more meals you order per week.
Where Dinnerly edges out is the first-order discount — often 60% off vs EveryPlate's ~50%. If you're trying both services, Dinnerly gives you a slightly better deal on the trial.
EveryPlate offers 25+ recipes weekly with dedicated family, veggie, and quick-meal filters. Dinnerly has 15–20 recipes and limited filtering. If you're making week-over-week subscriptions, EveryPlate's variety keeps menu fatigue at bay much longer.
A recurring Dinnerly complaint on Reddit and review sites: portions can run small, especially on the 2-person plans. EveryPlate's servings are more consistently satisfying. If you have larger appetites, consider sizing up on Dinnerly or going with EveryPlate.
Dinnerly uses 3–6 ingredients per recipe — among the simplest in the industry. EveryPlate recipes are also accessible but typically 6–10 ingredients with slightly more technique. Neither service is intimidating for beginner cooks.
Both services charge $9.99 shipping, which significantly affects per-meal cost on smaller plans. On a 2-person, 2-recipe plan (4 meals), you're paying $2.50 extra per meal just in shipping. The more meals you order, the more diluted that shipping cost gets — making larger plans a better deal on either service.
Choose EveryPlate if: You want more recipe variety week to week, need bigger portions, and value EveryPlate's slightly more polished ordering experience. For ongoing subscriptions, EveryPlate holds up better over time.
Choose Dinnerly if: You want the absolute lowest per-serving price, love ultra-simple recipes with minimal prep, or are cooking for picky kids. Dinnerly's first-order deal is also slightly better for trying it out.
Skip both if: You want no cooking at all. CookUnity delivers fully prepared, chef-made meals that heat in 2 minutes — and at $11.49–$15.99/meal after the 50% first-order discount, it's competitive with the per-meal cost of budget kits when you count your cooking time.
Dinnerly is slightly cheaper on a per-serving basis ($4.99 minimum vs EveryPlate's $4.99–$7.49). Both charge $9.99 flat shipping. Dinnerly also offers a larger first-order discount (~60% off). For ongoing use, the gap is small — especially on larger plans.
EveryPlate wins on variety with 25+ recipes weekly and better dietary filters (family, veggie, quick). Dinnerly offers 15–20 recipes weekly and fewer filters. For long-term subscriptions, EveryPlate's wider menu prevents fatigue.
Both deliver fresh ingredients and reliable recipes, but neither will blow you away on ingredient quality. They're optimized for cost, not premium produce. For better ingredient sourcing, consider HelloFresh, Sunbasket, or Green Chef — at a higher price point.
Yes — both services make pausing and canceling straightforward from your account settings. EveryPlate's cancelation flow (inherited from HelloFresh) is particularly simple. Just make sure to manage your delivery cutoff dates to avoid being charged for a box you don't want.
For no-cooking convenience, CookUnity delivers chef-prepared meals ready in 2 minutes. For better recipe quality and variety, HelloFresh or Sunbasket are upgrades. For keto/athlete-focused nutrition, Factor or Trifecta are the top picks.
CookUnity delivers 200+ chef-crafted meals weekly — fully prepared, ready in 2 minutes. No chopping, no pots, no cleanup.
Get 50% Off CookUnity →